Ghani Akbar, Muhammad Munir Ahmad, Abdul Ghafoor, Matiullah Khan, Zafar Islam


The conventional surface irrigation systems, border, level basin and furrow bed, are inherently inefficient in Pakistan, while the suboptimal field sizes (length and width) are considered as one of the main reasons of poor performance. Addressing these issues, the three surface irrigation systems were evaluated on thirteen fields under routine farmer management in Pakistan. Irrigation performance including application efficiency (AE), Potential Application Efficiency (PAE), Adequacy (AD) and distribution uniformity (DU), of 17 irrigation events were evaluated and further potential for improvement by optimising field sizes were identified using surface irrigation evaluation Model WinSRFR 4.1.3.

The study revealed poor irrigation efficiencies, AElq (41% to 82%), PAEmin (43% to 95%), ADlq (1.16 to 2.29) and DUlq (80% to 99%), on farms. The average AElq on farm was in the order of; level basin (58%) < border (65%) <furrow bed (68%). Simulation modelling indicated that there is further potential to increase average PAE up-to 94%, 87% and 96% for level basin, border and furrow bed irrigated fields respectively, by optimising field length and width. The analysis demonstrated increased understanding of the interactions of field sizes and irrigation efficiencies, which may support irrigators’ decision making for enhancing irrigation performance at no significant cost to infrastructure, machinery or labour.


Application efficiency; Adequacy; distribution uniformity; border; level basin; furrow bed

Full Text:



Mahmood A., Oweis T., Ashraf M., Majid A., Aftab M., and Aadal N., 2015. “Performance of improved practices in farmers’ fields under rainfed and supplemental irrigation systems in a semi-arid area of Pakistan”, Agricultural Water Management.155:1-10.

GOP 2013-14. “Agriculture Statistics: Pakistan Bureau of Statistics”, Government of Pakistan.

Qureshi A.S., 2015. “Improving food security and livelihood resilience through groundwater management in Pakistan”

World Bank 2008. “World Bank Development Indicators”, http://datafinder. about-world-development-indicators?cid=GPD_WDI.

World Bank 1997. “Staff appraisal report, Pakistan National Drainage Project. Washington DC”: World Bank;. Report No.: Report No. 1531U.

Zwart S.J., and Bastiaanssen W.G.M., 2004. “Review of measured crop water productivity values for irrigated wheat, rice, cotton and maize”. Agricultural Water Management.69(2):115-33.

Kalwij I.M., 1997. “Assessing the field irrigation performance and alternative management options for basin surface irrigation systems through hydrodynamic modelling”. Lahore, Pakistan: IWMI.

Akbar G., Hamilton G., Hussain Z., and Yasin M., 2007. “Problems and Potentials of permanent raised bed cropping systems in Pakistan”, Pakistan Journal of Water Resources.11(1):11-21.

Akbar G., Raine S., McHugh A., and Hamilton G., 2015. “Managing lateral infiltration on wide beds in clay and sandy clay loam using Hydrus 2D”. Irrigation Science. 33(3):177-90.

Akbar G., McHugh A.D., Raine S.R., and Hamilton G.J., 2011. “A preliminary evaluation of furrow inflow rate and cut-off time on the performance of smallholder raised bed farming systems”, World Congress on Conservation Agriculture. Brisbane Australia.

Gill M.A., 1994. “On-Farm Water Management: A historical overview. Water and Community: An Assessment of On-Farm Water Management Programme”, Islamabad: Sustainable Development Policy Institute (SDPI):24-39.

Gill M.A., Ahmad M., and Awan N.A., 2005. “Evaluation and performance of growing crops on permanent raised beds in Pakistan’s Punjab”, In: Roth C., Fischer R., Meisner C., eds. Evaluation and performance of permanent raised bed cropping systems in Asia, Australia and Mexico. Griffith, NSW, Australia: ACIAR:66-71.

Ashraf M., Nasir A., and Saeed M., 2010. “Evaluation of existing water productivity in the lower bari boab canal (LBDC) command - A case study”, Pak J Agri Sci.47(4):389-97.

Shafiq M., Hassan I., and Hussain Z., 2002. “Influence of Irrigation methods on the productivity of summer maize under saline/sodic environment”, Asian Journal of Plant Science.6:678-80.

Bautista E., Schlegel J.L., and Strelkoff T.S., 2012. “WinSRFR 4.1-User Manual. USDA-ARS Arid Land Agricultural Research Center”, No. 21881.

Roldán-Cañas J., Chipana R., Moreno-Pérez M.F., and Chipana G., 2015. “Description and Evaluation of Zigzag Furrow Irrigation in the Inter-Andean Valleys of Bolivia”, Journal of Irrigation and Drainage Engineering.141(11): No. 04015019.

Campo-Bescós M.A., Muñoz-Carpena R., Kiker G.A., Bodah B.W., and Ullman J.L., 2015. “Watering or buffering? Runoff and sediment pollution control from furrow irrigated fields in arid environments”. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment.205:90-101.

Ali M., 2011. “Irrigation System Designing. Practices of Irrigation & On-farm Water Management”: Volume 2: Springer:65-110.

Chen B., Ouyang Z., Sun Z., Wu L., and Li F., 2013. “Evaluation on the potential of improving border irrigation performance through border dimensions optimization: a case study on the irrigation districts along the lower Yellow River”, Irrigation Science.31(4):715-28.

González C., Cervera L., and Moret-Fernández D., 2011. “Basin irrigation design with longitudinal slope”, Agricultural water management.98(10):1516-22.

Bautista E., Clemmens A.J., Strelkoff T.S., and Niblack M., 2009. “Analysis of surface irrigation systems with WinSRFR—Example application”, Agricultural water management.96(7):1162-69.

Bautista E., Clemmens A.J., Strelkoff T.S., and Schlegel J., 2009. “Modern analysis of surface irrigation systems with WinSRFR”, Agricultural Water Management. 96(7):1146-54.

Philip J.R., 1969. “Theory of infiltration”, Advances in Hdroscience.5:215-96.

Raine S., and Bakker D., 1996. “Increased furrow irrigation efficiency through better design and management of cane fields”, Australian Society of Sugar Cane Technologists, Mackay 114-24.

Smith R., Raine S., and Minkevich J., 2005. “Irrigation application efficiency and deep drainage potential under surface irrigated cotton”, Agricultural Water Management.71(2):117-30.

Khatri K.L., 2007. “Toward real-time control of surface irrigation”, PhD thesis,. University of Southern Queensland (USQ), Toowoomba, Australia.

Gillies M.H., Smith R.J., Williamson B., and Shanahan M., 2010. “Improving performance of bay irrigation through higher flow rates”, Australian Irrigation Conference and Exibition 2010: One Water Many Futures. Sydney, Australia: Irrigation Australia Ltd.




  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c) 2017 Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences (JEAS), University of Engineering and Technology, Peshawar

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

ISSN: 1023-862X  & eISSN:2518-4571